Showing posts with label stats. Show all posts
Showing posts with label stats. Show all posts

Monday, 4 April 2016

Season Five: Ranking and Stats

season 5.jpg
Doctor Who: Season Five (1967/68)
2 September 1967 - 1 June 1968
The Second Doctor now comfy in the role, Patrick Troughton stars alongside Frazer Hines, as Jamie McCrimmon, and Deborah Watling, as Victoria Waterfield, in the fifth season of Doctor Who. While most fans acclaim the run highly, I found it to be the worst yet.
Here is my ranking of the seven stories:
  1. The Ice Warriors (9.5/10)
  2. The Web of Fear (8/10)
  3. Fury from the Deep (7/10)
  4. The Tomb of the Cybermen (6.5/10)
  5. The Enemy of the World (6/10)
  6. The Wheel in Space (6/10)
  7. The Abominable Snowmen (5/10)
According to my ratings season five had:
1 Amazing Episode (9+/10)
1 Great Episodes (8+/10)
1 Good Episode (7+/10)
3 Okay Episodes (6+/10)
1 Bad Episode (4+/10)

Averaging these out means season five has an average rating of…                               6.86/10And a range of                                                                                                                       4.5

Tuesday, 15 March 2016

Season 4 - Ranking and Stats


Doctor Who - Season Four (1966/67)
10 September 1966 - 1 July 1967

William Hartnell's last and Patrick Troughton's first, Season 4 of Doctor Who was a roller coaster throughout, providing us with unforgettable moments such as the first Cyberman appearance and the first ever regeneration. Season 4 is undeniably one of the biggest game-changing seasons, second only to the very first.

Ranking

  1. The Tenth Planet (9.5/10)
  2. The Evil of the Daleks (9/10)
  3. The Moonbase (9/10)
  4. The Highlanders (9/10)
  5. The Power of the Daleks (8/10)
  6. The Macra Terror (8/10)
  7. The Smugglers (7.5/10)
  8. The Underwater Menace (6/10)
  9. The Faceless Ones (5/10)
Averaging these out means Season Four has an average rating of...                  7.89/10

And a range of                                                                                                        4.5

From my ratings we can see Season Four had:
4 Amazing Episodes (9+/10)
2 Great Episodes (8+/10)
1 Good Episode (7+/10)
1 Okay Episode (6+/10)
1 Bad Episode (4+/10)
1 Terrible Episode (2+/10)

Here is a graph of my ratings:
The red line is the average. Click to enlarge.

Comparison

So far in our marathon we rated all over Season One, Two and Three's episodes, par the missing ones, so the averages could change when I get around to listening to the surviving audio or watching orphaned episodes.

In terms of average quality, Season Four comes in at second place, behind Season Two.

  1. Season Two - 7.94/10
  2. Season Four - 7.89/10
  3. Season One - 7.79/10
  4. Season Three - 7.5/10
In terms of range, it is in second as well. As so many Season Three episodes are missing, the range is counted from the only three surviving serials, so this is bound to change.
  1. Season Three - 2.5
  2. Season Four - 4.5
  3. Season One - 5.5
  4. Season Two - 8
That's all folks! Join us in two days time for a review of The Legends of Ashildr, the book, and following that: the first episode of Season Five: The Tomb of the Cybermen!

Friday, 11 March 2016

Companion Stats: Ben Jackson and Polly Wright

Names: Ben Jackson and Polly Wright
Actor/Actress: Michael Craze and Anneke Wills
Doctor/s: First and Second
Years: 1966 - 1967

Coming in right at the end of the Hartnell era, Ben and Polly traveled with the Doctor, and were the first companions to help the Doctor through his regeneration. The two intuitive and brave citizens of the swinging 60s were swept off in the TARDIS by accident, in The War Machines and stayed on until The Faceless Ones, one season and one Doctor later.

Episode Ranking

  1. The Tenth Planet (9.5/10)
  2. The War Machines (9/10)
  3. The Moonbase (9/10)
  4. The Highlanders (9/10)
  5. The Power of the Daleks (8/10)
  6. The Macra Terror (8/10)
  7. The Smugglers (7.5/10)
  8. The Underwater Menace (6/10)
  9. The Faceless Ones (5/10)

These average out to make...                                                                            7.89/10
With a range of...                                                                                                  4.5

We can also break this down into meaning Ben and Polly starred in...

4 Amazing Stories (9+/10)
2 Great Ones (8+/10)
1 Good One (7+/10)
1 Okay One (6+/10)
1 Bad One (4+/10)

In my opinion Ben and Polly are at their best in their debut, The War Machines, where they show their bravery and resourcefulness, displaying their suitability as companions.

Here is a graph showing the performance of Ben and Polly's run:

The red line represents their average (7.89/10). Click to enlarge.


Comparison

We can see the young pair come in at third place in terms of quality of episodes:
  1. Vicki Pallister - 8.08/10
  2. Steven Taylor - 8/10
  3. Ben Jackson and Polly Wright - 7.89/10
  4. Susan Foreman - 7.7/10
  5. Ian Chesterton and Barbara Wright - 7.65/10
  6. Dodo Chaplet - 7.5/10
And again, at third place, with consistency! Remember the lower the consistency the better!
  1. Dodo Chaplet - 2.5
  2. Steven Taylor - 3
  3. Ben Jackson and Polly Wright - 4.5
  4. Susan Foreman - 5.5
  5. Ian Chesterton and Barbara Wright - 8
  6. Vicki Pallister - 8
These results could differ (extremely so in Steven and Dodo's case) when I finally get round to reviewing the missing Hartnell episodes, so these standings are temporary.

Join us in two days time for the review of the Season 4 finale, The Evil of the Daleks!

Monday, 22 February 2016

Companion Stats: Dodo Chaplet

Names: Dodo Chaplet
Actress: Jackie Lane
Doctor/s: First
Year/s: 1966

Only properly in 4 serials, (with two the only remaining) Dodo is a highly overlooked companion, but for a good reason. Far too similar to Susan, Dodo didn't really bring anything new to the show (if accents that change half way through an episode don't count). In my opinion Dodo was fun and acted well along side Hartnell, and unfairly suffered the worst exit of any Doctor Who companion: no exit at all!

Episode Ranking

  1. The War Machines (9/10)
  2. The Gunfighters (7/10)
  3. The Ark (6.5/10)
N.A. The Celestial Toymaker
N.A. The Savages

Note: I haven't included The Massacre as she was only in it for the last episode, for a few minutes at the end.

These add up to give Dodo an average episode rating of...                               7.5/10
And a range of...                                                                                                  2.5

This can be broken down into:
1 Amazing Episode (9+/10)
1 Good Episode (7+/10)
1 Okay Episode (6+/10)

In my opinion, of the surviving episodes, Dodo is best in The Gunfighters where she displays both her feisty and also her cute side.

Here is a rather pointless graph showing her run of episodes:

As usual the red line shows the average.

Comparison

We can see Dodo comes in last place in terms of quality of episodes:
  1. Vicki Pallister - 8.08/10
  2. Steven Taylor - 8/10
  3. Susan Foreman - 7.7/10
  4. Ian Chesterton and Barbara Wright - 7.65/10
  5. Dodo Chaplet - 7.5/10
But she has the best consistency of episodes (remember: the lower the range, the better the consistency of quality of episodes):
  1. Dodo Chaplet - 2.5
  2. Steven Taylor - 3
  3. Susan Foreman - 5.5
  4. Ian Chesterton and Barbara Wright - 8
  5. Vicki Pallister - 8
And thus concludes the final companion to leave during the Hartnell era! Join us tomorrow for a breakthrough blog announcement! (Don't get too excited)


Sunday, 21 February 2016

Season 3 - Ranking and Stats


Doctor Who - Season Three (1965/66)
11 September 1965 - 16 July 1966

After two seasons, Doctor Who faced a season of cast changes, from Vicki to Katarina, to Sara to Dodo, to Steven and finally to Ben and Polly, making up for a interesting season that feels as if it is trying to find its feet.

As so many of the stories are missing, tragically including the 13-part epic, The Dalek's Master Plan, there isn't much to rank and the average could be dramatically changed if we ever get hold of Season 3's missing episodes.


  1. The War Machines (9/10)
  2. The Gunfighters (7/10)
  3. The Ark (6.5/10)
N.A. Galaxy Four (?/10)
N.A. Mission to the Unknown (?/10)
N.A. The Myth Makers (?/10)
N.A. The Dalek's Master Plan (?/10)
N.A. The Massacre of St. Bartholomew's Eve (?/10)
N.A. The Celestial Toymaker (?/10)
N.A. The Savages (?/10)

Averaging out the very limited amount of ratings means Season 3 has an average of...
                                                                                                                          7.5/10
And a range of...                                                                                                 2.5

From this we can see the remains of Season 3 had:
1 Amazing Episode (9+/10)
1 Good Episode (7+/10)
1 Okay Episode (6+/10)

Now for the (almost pointless) graph!


Comparison

As I'm only three seasons into my marathon there isn't a lot of results to go by so this is fairly limited...

  1. Season Two - 7.94/10
  2. Season One - 7.79/10
  3. Season Three - 7.5/10
On terms of range, Seasons Three takes the top spot, with only three stories surviving, meaning it is the most consistent season so far. (Remember: the lower the range, the more consistent the series)
  1. Season Three - 2.5
  2. Season One - 5.5
  3. Season Two - 8
Join us tomorrow for stats of Dodo Chaplet, the companion with only three surviving stories, the same three as Season 3's surviving ones.


Monday, 15 February 2016

Companion Stats - Vicki Pallister

Names: Vicki Pallister
Actress: Maureen O'Brien
Doctor/s: First
Year/s: 1964 - 1965

Replacing Susan, The Doctor's granddaughter, Vicki is a great improvement, thanks to O'Brien's superior acting and the character's badass-ery (I'm never using that word again).

Episode Ranking

  1. The Time Meddler (10/10)
  2. The Romans (10/10)
  3. The Rescue (9/10)
  4. The Space Museum (9/10)
  5. The Chase (8.5/10)
  6. The Web Planet (2/10)
N/A. The Crusade (?/10)
N/A. Galaxy Four (?/10)
N.A. The Myth Makers (?/10)

Averaging these out means she has an average rating of...                          8.08/10
And she has a range of...                                                                                   8

This means Vicki stars in:
2 Perfect Episodes (10/10)
2 Amazing Episodes (9+/10)
1 Great Episode (8+/10)
1 Terrible Episode (2+/10)

Unfortunately this doesn't include the three stories that are missing: The Crusade, Galaxy Four and The Myth Makers.

In my opinion, Vicki is at her best in The Space Museum as she encourages revolution on the planet Xeros and has a romance with one of the natives. I reckon this would have been The Myth Makers if it survived.

Here's a graph (remember the red line in the average):


Comparison

Compared to previous companions Vicki comes out on top in terms of quality of episodes:
  1. Vicki Pallister - 8.08/10
  2. Susan Foreman - 7.7/10
  3. Ian Chesterton and Barbara Wright - 7.65/10
And ties with Ian and Barbara in last place for the range (remember, the lower, the more consistent the quality of episodes):
  1. Susan Foreman - 5.5
  2. Ian Chesterton and Barbara Wright - 8
  3. Vicki Pallister - 8

Sunday, 14 February 2016

Season 2 - Ranking and Stats


Doctor Who - Season Two (1964/65)
31 October 1964 - 24 July 1965

After a successful first season, Doctor Who returned for a second season later in 1965, bigger and better than ever. Here I've ranked the episodes of Hartnell's second and best season. Click on the episodes to see the full reviews.

  1. The Time Meddler (10/10)
  2. The Romans (10/10)
  3. The Rescue (9/10)
  4. The Space Museum (9/10)
  5. The Chase (8.5/10)
  6. Planet of Giants (8/10)
  7. The Dalek Invasion of Earth (7/10)
  8. The Web Planet (2/10)
N/A. The Crusade (?/10)

Unfortunately The Crusade is missing, but from the remaining episodes I'm sure it would be up in the top three of the season.

Averaging these out means Season Two has an average rating of...                    7.94/10

And a range of                                                                                                        8.0


If it wasn't for The The Web Planet, my least favourite episode of Doctor Who... ever, Season Two would have an average of 8.79/10 which is an astoundingly high score!

From my ratings we can see Season Two had:
2 Perfect Episodes (10/10)
2 Amazing Episodes (9+/10)
2 Great Episodes (8+/10)
1 Good Episode (7+/10)
1 Terrible Episode (2+/10)

Now for the graph!


As you can see, because of The Web Planet's abnormally low score only two episodes fall below the average.


Comparison

As we're only two seasons into Doctor Who, not much can be compared, but we can see Season Two has a higher average than Season One.
  1. Season Two - 7.94/10
  2. Season One - 7.79/10
But on the terms of range, Season One is much more consistent with its episodes, with a range lower than Season Two. (Remember: the lower the range, the more consistent the series)
  1. Season One - 5.5
  2. Season Two - 8
Join us tomorrow for the next Doctor Who review!